Disclaimer  These lists are unofficial, they are not in any way condoned or supported by Windstone Editions. They are taken directly from personal accounts that were encountered of good or bad business practices, and have nothing to do with  Windstone Editions whatsoever, nor with ebay. This is an initiative to keep these lists up-to-date for forum members, old and new, in order to avoid scammers or simply to find out who are good sellers/buyers. The lists are maintained by drag0nfreathers, while I host them. These lists are a compilation of objective accounts, nothing more, nothing less. No names will be added without reason, either good or bad. If you want a name added, you must provide details – this goes for all lists. Positive Feedback submissions generally do not require evidence or investigation to be submitted, just a description of the transaction; we tend to include those comments verbatim Negative and neutral feedback will always require evidence in the form of uncropped screenshots or other context in an unaltered form to prove one's case prior to submitting said complaint. The feedback must be lodged in the first person by the person who is submitting said complaint. You cannot submit feedback for someone else. Though this does not occur often, it is important to know that your feedback could be disputed, so be 100% factual with your experience to avoid being challenged. If you do see a negative comment about yourself, you can contest it with proof also (like a reply on eBay feedback). This is meant to be fair and objective. For a rebuttal, you must supply the same evidence as the complainant. It’s never fun to find negative feedback about yourself, but do remain professional when you submit your rebuttal, otherwise, it will not be considered. We will not divulge who asked to have the names posted, but any detail will probably allow the person named to figure out who made the request. We will not be held responsible for any action/ communication resulting from any name or comment posted here. These are factual lists and must not be seen as anything else. We do not judge, we do not investigate, we simply sort through all the information and add an objective comment. Remember that we all end up having good and bad dealings at one point - these lists are meant to help, they are not set in stone. In fact, a sale/trade with a member who has a huge amount of good feedback can end up being the worst transaction you make and vice versa. It's up to you decide what to make of the feedback when you sell, trade or buy - not us or anyone else!  The following lists are included in a PDF format: a positive feedback list, a negative feedback list, a neutral feedback list and a commissions list for people who wish to get references before commissioning an artist. If you want to add a comment on any of the lists, send a PM to drag0nfeathers. She will be handling the updates, while I host the documents. Do NOT contact me.  Dragonmedley  Last update: October 14, 2024 Positive feedback Negative feedback Neutral feedback